next up previous
Next: Modelling and analysis Up: Exploring sensitivity for exchangeable Previous: Exchangeability

Problem summary

In [10] we considered an industrial process for extracting aluminium by electrolysis from a solution of alumina. Experiments are performed, under similar operating conditions, to measure the percentage concentration of alumina in solution every ten minutes, terminating when the concentration falls to a prespecified level. The measurements are the responses tex2html_wrap_inline2397 representing, for runs j, the concentrations of alumina remaining in solution at thirteen time points i timed from the end of the experiment (the alumina level is essentially fixed at the end of the experiment). A key property of the process is that the experiments are exchangeable, and one aim of the analysis will be to assess the underlying mean values of the process. Data is available for three runs of the process.

The following exchangeable regressions model (an adaptation of the localised regression model introduced in [11] and of the dynamic linear model discussed in [13]), which takes into account various physical determinants and complicating features, was suggested to represent the process.

    eqnarray689

The intercepts tex2html_wrap_inline2373 and the slopes tex2html_wrap_inline2375 are second-order exchangeable over runs, tex2html_wrap_inline2377 , and the tex2html_wrap_inline2373 are uncorrelated with the tex2html_wrap_inline2375 . We allow for the regression slopes to drift slowly over time, and so introduce strong correlations between neighbouring slopes and choose a correlation function so that the slopes have the markov property in being mutually uncorrelated given their neighbours. One way of achieving this aim is to use the following correlation function:

displaymath2371

where, for convenience, we define tex2html_wrap_inline2385 to be the correlation between the most distant slopes tex2html_wrap_inline2403 and tex2html_wrap_inline2405 , so that values of tex2html_wrap_inline2387 describe the degree of local stability. As we expect only minor regression drift, we feel that values of about tex2html_wrap_inline2389 , giving a correlation of about 0.9913 between neighbouring slopes, might be appropriate. Smaller values of tex2html_wrap_inline2391 will still yield high neighbouring correlations, but the dependencies between slopes will tail off much more quickly.

The error term tex2html_wrap_inline2407 is constructed from uncorrelated components representing various error terms: simple noise, a random walk with drift, and an autoregressive term. (Full details of the development of the error structure can be found in [4].)

To assess the sensitivity of the model to changes in the stability parameter, and so discover whether our actual choice needs careful thought, we construct the model for a range of values of tex2html_wrap_inline2391 and estimate the regression slopes. We assess the overall implications of changing the stability parameter by evaluating the structure of the resolution transform for each tex2html_wrap_inline2391 .


next up previous
Next: Modelling and analysis Up: Exploring sensitivity for exchangeable Previous: Exchangeability

David Wooff
Thu Oct 15 11:27:04 BST 1998